| Grace Like Rain (Todd Agnew) | Angie Hinnegan |
| I Keep Falling in Love With Him (Lanny Wolfe) | Terry Ratliff |
| Light Up the Sky (The Afters) | Grace & Amy Larson |
| Made to Worship (Chris Tomlin) | Leah & Jodi Reed |
| Your Great Name | Ben & Inger |
| Your Love is Like a River (Third Day) | Grace & Amy Larson |
